Reviewer Guide

 
For Reviewers

Reviewer Guide

Standards, Responsibilities, and Procedures for Peer Review

JIPI Cover

Overview

Jurnal Inovasi Pajak Indonesia (JIPI) upholds a rigorous peer-review process to ensure the publication of high-quality, innovative, and impactful research in taxation. This guide outlines the roles, responsibilities, and ethical standards expected from our reviewers, who play a pivotal role in maintaining the integrity of our scholarly record.

Reviewer Responsibilities

  • Provide Constructive Feedback: Offer objective, clear, and specific critiques to help authors improve their manuscript.
  • Maintain Confidentiality: Treat submitted manuscripts as strictly confidential documents. Do not discuss or share them.
  • Identify Ethical Concerns: Immediately report any suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, or other unethical practices.
  • Ensure Timely Review: Submit reviews within the agreed deadline (typically 3 weeks).

Ethical Standards

  • Conflicts of Interest: Disclose any potential conflicts (financial, institutional, or personal) that may influence your evaluation.
  • Fair & Unbiased: Reviews must be free from bias related to nationality, religious or political beliefs, gender, or other personal characteristics.
  • Double-Blind Process: JIPI follows a double-blind review policy. Ensure your report does not inadvertently reveal your identity.

Evaluation Criteria

1. Originality

Does the manuscript present new insights, theories, or methodologies? Is the topic relevant and impactful?

2. Methodology

Are methods appropriate and well-explained? Is data analysis rigorous, transparent, and reproducible?

3. Clarity

Is the manuscript well-structured and logically organized? Are tables and figures relevant and clear?

4. Contribution

Does the study provide theoretical advancements or practical implications for policymakers?

Timelines & Recommendations
Reviewers must select one of the following:
Accept as is Accept with minor revisions Revise & Resubmit Reject
Standard Processing Time (90 Days Total)
30
Days
Initial Decision
30
Days
Revision Process
30
Days
Final Publication

Reviewer Recognition

JIPI values your contribution to science. We offer:

  • Certificates of recognition for outstanding contributions.
  • Opportunities to join the Editorial Board.
  • Annual Acknowledgment in our end-of-year report.

Contact Us

For inquiries regarding the review process or technical issues, please contact the editorial office:

Email: admin@analysisdata.co.id
Website: analysisdata.co.id

© Jurnal Inovasi Pajak Indonesia (JIPI). Published by PT. Inovasi Analisis Data.