- Make a Submission
- Focus and Scope
- Editorial Team
- Reviewers
- Author Guidelines
- Reviewer Guidelines
- Article Template
- Article Processing Charge (APC)
- Publication Process
- Publication Ethics
- Plagiarism Policy
- Recommended Tools
- Generative AI Policies
- Open Access Statement
- Copyright and License
- Archiving Policy
- Crossmark Policy
- Indexing
- Scopus Citedness
- Contact Us
- Support
Plagiarism
Academic Integrity Policy
Plagiarism Policy & Statement
Sharia Economic Law Innovation (SELI)
Sharia Economic Law Innovation (SELI) is committed to maintaining originality, academic honesty, and integrity in scholarly publishing. Plagiarism, duplicate publication, improper paraphrasing, fabricated references, citation manipulation, and any form of academic misconduct are strictly prohibited. This policy applies to all manuscripts submitted to SELI, including research articles, review articles, conceptual papers, and other scholarly contributions.
1. Definition of Plagiarism
Plagiarism refers to the use of another person’s words, ideas, data, theories, figures, tables, arguments, or research findings without proper acknowledgment. It also includes presenting another author’s intellectual contribution as one’s own work.
- Copying text directly from another source without quotation marks and proper citation.
- Paraphrasing another author’s work without appropriate acknowledgment.
- Using ideas, theories, data, figures, tables, or research instruments without citation.
- Submitting the same or substantially similar manuscript to more than one journal.
- Reusing the author’s own previously published work without proper citation or disclosure.
- Using translated material from another source without proper attribution.
- Submitting manuscripts containing fabricated references, false citations, or unsupported academic claims.
2. Forms of Plagiarism and Similarity Misconduct
Direct Plagiarism
Copying text word-for-word without quotation marks, citation, or permission where required.
Mosaic Plagiarism
Combining copied phrases or sentence structures from several sources without proper citation.
Self-Plagiarism
Reusing previously published work, data, or text without citation or editorial disclosure.
Duplicate Publication
Submitting or publishing substantially similar manuscripts in different journals without transparency.
Improper Paraphrasing
Changing only a few words from a source while retaining the original structure or meaning without citation.
Fabricated Citation
Using references that do not exist, are inaccurate, or do not support the stated argument.
3. Manuscript Screening and Detection
All manuscripts submitted to SELI may be screened using similarity detection software such as Turnitin, iThenticate, or equivalent tools. Similarity screening is conducted to support originality, citation integrity, and responsible publication practice.
Similarity Threshold: SELI recommends a similarity index of ≤ 12%, excluding references, quotations, standard methodological terms, and common phrases. However, editorial judgment is not based solely on percentage. The quality, source, and nature of the similarity will also be evaluated.
Manuscripts with excessive similarity, unattributed content, improper paraphrasing, citation manipulation, or suspicious references may be returned for revision, rejected before review, or investigated further by the editorial team.
4. Author Responsibilities
Authors are fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, and integrity of their manuscripts. Before submission, authors must ensure that all sources are properly cited, references are accurate, and no part of the manuscript violates academic ethics.
- Submit only original manuscripts that have not been published or submitted elsewhere.
- Use proper citation and quotation for all borrowed ideas, text, data, tables, and figures.
- Ensure that all references are real, accurate, relevant, and traceable.
- Avoid excessive text recycling from previous publications.
- Provide a similarity report when requested by the editorial team.
- Correct any ethical or citation problems identified during editorial screening or peer review.
- Ensure all co-authors approve the manuscript before submission.
- Disclose any use of generative AI tools where applicable.
5. AI Use, Originality, and Citation Integrity
SELI recognizes that AI-assisted tools may support academic writing when used responsibly. However, authors must ensure that AI tools do not compromise originality, research integrity, citation accuracy, or ethical responsibility.
Important AI Declaration: Authors must declare the use of AI tools if they were used for drafting, language improvement, translation, summarization, or manuscript preparation support. AI tools must not be used to generate fake data, fabricated references, false citations, unsupported theories, manipulated results, or misleading claims. The final responsibility for all manuscript content remains with the author(s).
6. Editorial Actions and Consequences
If plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated references, or other forms of misconduct are detected before or after publication, SELI will take appropriate action based on the severity of the case and the stage of publication.
| Before Peer Review | The manuscript may be returned to the author for correction or rejected during editorial screening. |
|---|---|
| During Peer Review | The manuscript may be withdrawn from review, rejected, or investigated further. |
| After Acceptance | Acceptance may be cancelled if ethical violations are identified before publication. |
| After Publication | The journal may issue a correction, expression of concern, retraction, or notification to relevant institutions when necessary. |
7. Reviewer and Editor Responsibilities
Reviewers and editors are expected to support plagiarism prevention by identifying possible ethical issues during the editorial and peer review process.
- Reviewers should report suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, or unethical citation practices to the editor.
- Editors should investigate suspected misconduct fairly and confidentially.
- Editors may request clarification, raw data, similarity reports, or additional documentation from authors.
- Editorial decisions must be based on evidence, academic merit, and ethical standards.
8. Ethical Commitment
SELI is committed to fostering a culture of academic integrity, transparency, and responsible publication. Authors, reviewers, editors, and the publisher share responsibility for maintaining the credibility of scholarly communication and protecting the integrity of the academic record.
Originality is the foundation of scholarly contribution, and integrity is the foundation of publication ethics.
SELI is committed to ensuring that every published article reflects responsible and ethical academic practice.
Sharia Economic Law Innovation (SELI)
Published by PT. Inovasi Analisis Data
Email: seli@analysisdata.co.id










