Reviewer Guide

Reviewer Guide: Advances in Administration (AVITI)

Welcome and Introduction

Welcome to the reviewer community of Advances in Administration (AVITI). As a reviewer, your expertise and insights are invaluable in maintaining the high standards of our journal. This guide provides essential information and guidelines to assist you in the review process.

1. Role and Responsibilities of Reviewers

Confidentiality: All manuscripts and review materials are confidential. Do not share or discuss them with anyone outside the review process.
Objectivity: Provide an unbiased, constructive, and fair assessment of the manuscript. Focus on the content without personal bias.
Timeliness: Complete your review within the agreed timeframe. If you need an extension, please contact the editorial office as soon as possible.
Conflict of Interest: Inform the editor if you have any conflicts of interest that might affect your ability to provide an impartial review.

2. Review Process

Initial Assessment: Assess the manuscript's relevance to the journal's focus and scope. Determine if the manuscript makes a significant contribution to the field of administration.
Detailed Review: Evaluate the manuscript based on the following criteria:
- Originality and Novelty: Does the manuscript present new and original findings?
- Methodology: Is the research design and methodology sound and appropriate?
- Clarity and Cohesion: Is the manuscript well-organized and clearly written?
- Data and Analysis: Are the data presented accurately and analyzed appropriately?
- Conclusions: Are the conclusions supported by the data and analysis?
- References: Are the references current and relevant?

3. Reviewer Comments

Summary: Provide a brief summary of the manuscript and your overall impression.
Major and Minor Issues: Clearly distinguish between major issues (e.g., methodological flaws) and minor issues (e.g., typos).
Constructive Feedback: Offer constructive suggestions for improvement. Be specific and detailed in your comments.
Recommendation: Provide a clear recommendation using the following options:
- Accept
- Minor revisions
- Major revisions
- Reject

4. Submitting Your Review

Online System: Submit your review through the journal's online submission system. Follow the instructions provided in the review invitation email.
Review Form: Complete the review form, including your detailed comments and recommendation.

5. Post-Review

Revisions: If the manuscript is revised and resubmitted, you may be asked to review the revised version. Focus on the changes made and whether they address your previous concerns.
Feedback: Your feedback is important to us. If you have suggestions for improving the review process or the journal, please share them with the editorial office.

Conclusion

Your contribution as a reviewer is crucial to the success of Advances in Administration (AVITI). Thank you for your dedication and commitment to maintaining the high standards of our journal. If you have any questions or need assistance, please do not hesitate to contact the editorial office.

Contact Information